A trial of Discourse for Plain Text Accounting discussions

Site
21

I turned down a lot of the Discourse default chattiness, to be less jarring for the current mostly technical user base, but which emails did you find still bothersome ?

Late reply, but thanks for this. I believe I was thinking in general about Discourse forums, but realized Discourse’s email setup can be a bit more flexible than other platforms. For example, I personally ended up disabling the ‘activity summary’ thing for now (may consider turning it back on at a weekly or monthly basis later, daily is too much), and enabling “Email me when I am quoted, replied to, my @username is mentioned”

Perhaps I would suggest changing the default for summary emails to weekly.

22

Understood. The daily summary emails by default are a temporary thing while the site is in “bootstrap mode” - once it has enough users it switches to week summaries by default. I might do it sooner.

1 Like
23

Ok, I have changed the digest emails’ default frequency from daily to weekly (for everyone).

1 Like
24

I really like the use of Discourse as a replacement for Reddit. Never liked Reddit and always found it a bit cumbersome for many reasons. Several other forums I am part of have been using Discourse for some time now and everyone seems very happy with it.

The chats are nice for instant help but I find that I am a bit hesitant to ask simple questions that most likely been answered ten times before. And more complex discussions are always nice to learn from, something I think a forum of this type facilitate better.

Not a very tech savvy person, but I have been using PTA for a few years now, last year or so hledger, and hope to be able to contribute to the community in one way or another.

4 Likes
25

Thanks, this is an aspect of chat rooms I’m now more aware of.

26

(The busy IRC rooms I’m familiar with do not seem to have this problem, the opposite if anything :rofl: )

1 Like
27

Related:

2 Likes
PTA forum news, 2024-03-18
28

As we are plain text accounting, why don't we use plain text forum? Would such technology exist?

29

Like a mail list ? Do you think it would get traction ?

There's Ledger, hledger, and Beancount mail lists (sleeping, sleeping, and lively respectively).

1 Like
30

In addition to what Simon said, there are a number of “traditional” type forum softwares still around, but a lot of the kids nowadays would probably find them “dated” (aesthetically).

I am an old school IRC and Emacs user, and am allergic to JS, “web 2.0”, progressive loading pages and all the rest of the “modern web” but even I don’t find Discourse too bad, especially considering alternatives.

31 
As we are plain text accounting, why don't we use plain text
forum? Would such technology exist?

[... 3 lines elided]

I am an old school IRC and Emacs user, and am allergic to JS, “web
2.0”, progressive loading pages and all the rest of the “modern web”
but even I don’t find Discourse too bad, especially considering
alternatives.

You can use Discourse forum completely using email. I am interacting
with the Discourse forum here using mu4e inside emacs. Discourse makes
it work like a mailing list.

2 Likes